At the 20th Fiqh Seminar of Majlis e Shari, Al Jamiatul Ashrafia Mubarakpur, held at Aligarh from 17 to 19 May 2013, it was agreed with consensus that performing Fard Salah in a moving train, in India during present time is permissible and this Salah need not be repeated. The " Akhtari Camp" went against this verdict and started attacking Mufti Nizamuddin, who is the Chief Mufti of Al Jamiatul Ashrafia. Mufti Nizamuddin provided a detailed ruling in the light of Hnafai fiqh which proves the validity of his fatawa. This reply can be downloaded from our archives.The" Akhtari Camp" was answer less to this reply. Resorting to the lowest level, the Akhtari camp started threatening Mufti Nizamuddin and abusing him on phone calls. Mufti Nizamuddin has now written a detailed book on the issue of "Rulings in Hanafi Fiqh with the effect of new age and changing time " ( Fiqh Hanafi mein Halaat Zamaana ki Riaayat) in which he has provided a deep