During the time of Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Raza Khan Rahmatullah alayh, the running and management of trains in India was under the British control. The British used to stop train as per their convenience and pleasure. Ala Hazrat wrote that Salah performed on a moving train under these conditions and management must be repeated when one gets down from the train.
However, in the present conditions, the running and management of trains is under Indian Railways. The running and stopping of the trains are fixed. The train stops only at its official and schedule stops. ( We are not talking about illegal stops, break downs etc. Stopping the train by pulling chain or activating vacuum break is illegal ) Even if a minister is traveling in a train , he cannot make the train stop as per his convenience. The train stops only at the schedule stops.
This is one example to prove that as far as running of trains in India is concerned, conditions have changed in India. Due to this changed condition and other reasons, the sunni muftis and scholars of India are of the opinion that now salah performed in a moving train need not be repeated. The blog contains many books and articles on this topic.
It is well known to the students of dars e nizami that in matters of fiqh and furu, if the conditions change the rulings also change in some cases. However, the members of the Akhtari cult insist that all the furu and fiqh rulings of fatwa ridawiya must be followed even when the circumstances and conditions have changed. To these cult members we present the following fatwa from Fatwa Ridawiya: Fatwa Ridawiya, Vol. 16, p. 233 to 241:
http://www.alahazratnetwork.org/modules/booksofalahazrat/item.php?page=225&itemid=32
In answering a question Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Raza rahmatullah alayh writes that use of electric fan and electric bulb is not permissible.
This fatwa was issued some 100 years back due to conditions at that time mentioned in the fatwa .Since Akhtari cult members insist that they must follow fatwa ridawiya in every respect, all the Akhtari members should stop using electric bulb and electric fan !!!!
However, in the present conditions, the running and management of trains is under Indian Railways. The running and stopping of the trains are fixed. The train stops only at its official and schedule stops. ( We are not talking about illegal stops, break downs etc. Stopping the train by pulling chain or activating vacuum break is illegal ) Even if a minister is traveling in a train , he cannot make the train stop as per his convenience. The train stops only at the schedule stops.
This is one example to prove that as far as running of trains in India is concerned, conditions have changed in India. Due to this changed condition and other reasons, the sunni muftis and scholars of India are of the opinion that now salah performed in a moving train need not be repeated. The blog contains many books and articles on this topic.
It is well known to the students of dars e nizami that in matters of fiqh and furu, if the conditions change the rulings also change in some cases. However, the members of the Akhtari cult insist that all the furu and fiqh rulings of fatwa ridawiya must be followed even when the circumstances and conditions have changed. To these cult members we present the following fatwa from Fatwa Ridawiya: Fatwa Ridawiya, Vol. 16, p. 233 to 241:
http://www.alahazratnetwork.org/modules/booksofalahazrat/item.php?page=225&itemid=32
In answering a question Ala Hazrat Imam Ahmad Raza rahmatullah alayh writes that use of electric fan and electric bulb is not permissible.
This fatwa was issued some 100 years back due to conditions at that time mentioned in the fatwa .Since Akhtari cult members insist that they must follow fatwa ridawiya in every respect, all the Akhtari members should stop using electric bulb and electric fan !!!!
Roman Urdu will not be allowed.
ReplyDelete