Replies from Molvi Zia al Mustafa camp
Molvi Zia al Mustafa and his gang is of the opinion that Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi’s book ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa Maslak’ is against the Sunni belief. Molvi Zia al Mustafa repeated this accusation at Urs e Razvi as well. Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi published an open letter and made personal contact with Molvi Zia al Mustafa requesting him to pin point the mistakes in ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa Maslak’. Mawlana Yaseen went on record saying that if there is anthting in his book which is against the teachings of Ahlus sunnah then he will not only delete it in the next edition but will also seek public tawba ( repentence). It has been more than two months; no reoply has come from Molvi Zia al Mustafa. [The fact is that there is nothing in the book which is against Ahlus Sunnah]. It is known that Molvi Zia al mustafa camp often uses pseudo identity to publish articles. Zia al Mustafa realized that he has committed a blunder by accusing a major Sunni scholar of promoting “sulah kulliyat” but there is no proof for this!! If he pinpoints something from the book ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa maslak’ which he thinks is promoting ‘sulah kulliyat’ but later if the scholars do not agree to this, then he will be exposed. His hatred for Jamia Ashrafia will be public! His status as a scholar of hadith will be questioned! So Molvi Zia al Mustafa asked Hashmi (son of Molvi Siraj Azhar of Mumbai) to write an article against Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar! Let the readers know that Hashami is not even a certified molvi; forget about being al aalim or a fazil! He can’t read basic Arabic text! His father, Molvi Siraj Azhar is a big fitna monger. He has connections with anti social elements that is why people are scared of him. We have discussed in our other article how Hashim in one of his booklets openly threatened Mawlana Yaseen Akhar Misbahi. Interested readers can check archives to get the exact quote. There have been two replies from Molvi Zia al Mustafa camp; one by Hashim and other by an unknown (most probably a pseudo name) person Shafi al rehman naeemi. We have attached both the so called ‘refutation’.
What is disheartening and astonishing is that Qadi al Qudat fil Hind; Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan names one of this ‘refutations’ as an ‘academic’ reply to Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi! We have attached the presedential address my Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan so that readers can judge that instead of Fatwa Ridawiya, Fath al qadeer, Bahr al Raiq etc, we have a two page reply without reference, which is used by Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan!!
It is because of these reasons many scholars are of the opinion that Molvi Zia al Mustafa has used Mufti Akhtar Raza as a puppet!!
Molvi Zia al Mustafa and his gang is of the opinion that Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi’s book ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa Maslak’ is against the Sunni belief. Molvi Zia al Mustafa repeated this accusation at Urs e Razvi as well. Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi published an open letter and made personal contact with Molvi Zia al Mustafa requesting him to pin point the mistakes in ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa Maslak’. Mawlana Yaseen went on record saying that if there is anthting in his book which is against the teachings of Ahlus sunnah then he will not only delete it in the next edition but will also seek public tawba ( repentence). It has been more than two months; no reoply has come from Molvi Zia al Mustafa. [The fact is that there is nothing in the book which is against Ahlus Sunnah]. It is known that Molvi Zia al mustafa camp often uses pseudo identity to publish articles. Zia al Mustafa realized that he has committed a blunder by accusing a major Sunni scholar of promoting “sulah kulliyat” but there is no proof for this!! If he pinpoints something from the book ‘Irfan e Mazhab wa maslak’ which he thinks is promoting ‘sulah kulliyat’ but later if the scholars do not agree to this, then he will be exposed. His hatred for Jamia Ashrafia will be public! His status as a scholar of hadith will be questioned! So Molvi Zia al Mustafa asked Hashmi (son of Molvi Siraj Azhar of Mumbai) to write an article against Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar! Let the readers know that Hashami is not even a certified molvi; forget about being al aalim or a fazil! He can’t read basic Arabic text! His father, Molvi Siraj Azhar is a big fitna monger. He has connections with anti social elements that is why people are scared of him. We have discussed in our other article how Hashim in one of his booklets openly threatened Mawlana Yaseen Akhar Misbahi. Interested readers can check archives to get the exact quote. There have been two replies from Molvi Zia al Mustafa camp; one by Hashim and other by an unknown (most probably a pseudo name) person Shafi al rehman naeemi. We have attached both the so called ‘refutation’.
What is disheartening and astonishing is that Qadi al Qudat fil Hind; Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan names one of this ‘refutations’ as an ‘academic’ reply to Mawlana Yaseen Akhtar Misbahi! We have attached the presedential address my Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan so that readers can judge that instead of Fatwa Ridawiya, Fath al qadeer, Bahr al Raiq etc, we have a two page reply without reference, which is used by Mufti Akhtar Raza Khan!!
It is because of these reasons many scholars are of the opinion that Molvi Zia al Mustafa has used Mufti Akhtar Raza as a puppet!!
Comments
Post a Comment